Singapore Airlines versus Tiger Beer – why brands are admired or not in Singapore

Why is Singapore Airlines the most admired brand in Singapore and yet Tiger Beer is only 83rd?

Tiger Beer seems to have a marketing problem. Anyone who has seen one of their adverts or been to one of their numerous events will have seen several different creative executions appealing to very different target audiences. Half the adverts feature international expats and half the adverts feature Singaporeans. Never do the two meet. The football adverts are very focused on expats whereas the getting together to share the Tiger experience always appear to be focused at Singaporeans. However both groups see both sets of creative and therefore must wonder why they are sending out different messages to different people. The football adverts will also have turned off half the targeted audience as they featured Wayne Rooney who people either love or hate and is not especially admired by anyone, prostitutes and Alex Ferguson aside.

I always think that events are a poor man’s way of marketing, they don’t actually reach many people (only the people attending or those who see it in the press – if its featured which they mostly are not as media see right through them as being cheap marketing stunts) and are a very high cost per customer’s opportunity to see/experience. They are mostly to satisfy marketing director’s egos or board of director’s whims to make them feel good about their brand. They are surrounded by people who love the brand….but there aren’t many of them and they don’t reflect the broader spectrum of customers so they get a skewed view of how well the marketing and brand are going down. Tiger do a lot of events which might explain why they are not especially admired in Singapore. They think they’re doing a great job because that’s what they get told at events whereas the wider public disagrees but the directors never get to hear their views.

The Tiger Translates series of events and art inspirations really contradicts the football and male focus of the main marketing. It’s almost as though Tiger are marketing a different brand through Translates that they are trying to appeal to a different audience through. To most people it’s confusing. It can’t be both arty and football focused and when one target audience sees the other side surely that sends different messages and then turns a customer off rather than enhancing their brand affinity?

I wonder if the introduction of Tiger Crystal through high end bars and not available at retail is an attempt by Tiger to become more aspirational and admired. If so they will have to compete with the historical fact that Tiger was given away (and I think still is), to the Singapore Army free so was always viewed as being a working man’s beer and a staple to get through the day rather than an aspirational brand.

Considering the massive amounts of money that Tiger spends in Singapore and globally marketing itself, the fact that this is its home and you see the brand everywhere and it is locally recognized as being a global standard bearer for Singapore I would have thought it would be more admired. But trying to be all things to all men in its marketing has clearly confused its brand values. It’s meowing rather than roaring!

Singapore Airlines on the other hand is very Singaporean. They do what they say they will but nothing more and nothing less. They are not risk takers in their marketing or in their product and service delivery. They are a polished brand that make you feel good when you travel with them. But they are not exciting or thrilling or even especially adored or that people can get passionate about.

They are admired for all the reasons of quality of service and customer experience that you would imagine from a 5 star airline. But I wonder whether they are admired as you admire your Uncle or Aunt for setting up their own consultancy or chartered accountancy firm nor admired as you might passionately admire a famous footballer who scores an amazing goal or a rock star that delivers a heartbreaking song so passionately you feel his pain and relate to the experience. Nike, Apple, Google deliver excitement, wonder and passionate admiration and yet they were all beaten by Singapore Airlines in the most admired list. Is that because Singapore citizens prefer safe to exciting, trusted to thrilling, emotionless to passionate?

Chris Reed, Regional Partnerships Director (Asia), Partnership Marketing